Lady in the Lake Review and Short Summary

In 2018, Laura Lippman released Sunburn, a tantalizing thriller hailed as a “page-turning pleasure”, “handled with masterly flair”, and “lethally seductive”. Her new release, Lady in the Lake, is deserving of the same praise, and more. This vivid historical novel inspired by two real deaths (one solved, one unsolved) confirms Lippman’s status as one of the most skilled and prolific authors of American crime fiction and makes for a desirable, unforgiving dive into Sixties Baltimore.

Check out the latest price on Amazon

Interested in buying Lady in the Lake? Check out its most affordable price on Amazon for both the paperback and ebook version.

How Lady in the Lake naturally came into being

The story told in Lady in the Lake began, in many ways, five decades before the book’s release, in 1969. In June of that year, the body of Shirley Lee Wigeon Parker, a black 35-year-old divorcee, was found in a fountain in one of the city’s parks. About three months later, in September, Esther Lebowitz, an 11-year-old Jewish girl, was beaten to death inside a fish store, in a gruesome, traumatizing killing that profoundly impacted Baltimore’s Jewish community.

Discovery of Esther Lebowitz' body in 1969 in Baltimore. Mirrored by the the lady in the lake character Tessie Fine
Discovery of Esther Lebowitz in 1969

Those two stories collide in Lady in the Lake when Maddie Schwartz, a freshly divorced, 37-year-old former housewife, encounters the body of a recently murdered schoolgirl called Tessie Fine (whose story mirrors Esther Lebowitz’s). Maddie, who needs a job and, more importantly, a new identity besides being her husband’s former wife, turns the incident first into a story, then lands herself a bottom of the ladder job at the fictional (but delightfully realistic) Baltimore Star.

There, she becomes obsessed with the disappearance and drowning of Cleo Sherwood. The novel’s version of Shirley Lee Wigeon Parker and the novel’s titular Lady in the Lake. What follows is the tale of Maddie’s dogged determination to find out what happened to Cleo in the days before her death, and her equally staunch desire to carve herself a spot at the newspaper.

Black and white photo of a reporter, like lady in the lake character Maddie

From Housewife to Skilled Reporter

While Maddie’s metamorphosis from a skilled but bored housewife to a rookie reporter is the beating heart of Lady in the Lake, Lippman invites us, time and time again, to see Maddie’s journey as one element of a larger picture. One moving part in Baltimore’s complex dynamics.

She does so, mainly, by bringing to life a large cast of voices, including Cleo’s, who’s speaking from beyond the grave and isn’t particularly pleased by Maddie’s efforts to uncover the truth behind her disappearance. We hear from Tessie Fine’s presumed murderer, from Tessie herself (in her last moments), from an obliviously racist cop, a rising baseball star, and an experienced female reporter who is used to working on her copy in the women’s bathroom

Laura Lippman author of Lady in the Lake

How Lady in the Lake’s character Maddie somewhat reflects Lippman’s life

Lippman, a Baltimore resident, and former Baltimore Sun reporter takes her time to paint a full picture of her city, and her evident pleasure in doing so is infectious. It’s not always a comfortable picture, mind you set a full decade after the end of racial segregation in the United States, Lippman’s novel depicts the remaining blatant racism of the Sixties. A black police officer isn’t allowed to use a patrol car.

Baltimore City

The disappearance of Sherwood, a woman of colour, is ignored by most newspapers. One of the most moving scenes in the book comes when Maddie, having begun a secret liaison with the aforementioned black police officer, goes with him to a baseball game and must pretend not to know him. (Interracial marriage didn’t become legal in the United States until 1967, and that particular scene is set in July 1966.) “She almost touched Ferdie just then, but realized in time that she could not,” Lippman writes of Maddie and her lover.

“She had a ticket, he had a ticket. It was happenstance that they were seated together. They chatted as strangers in a stadium might, polite and distant.”

Sexuality is another important topic in the book

Through the mention of “Baltimore bachelors”, closeted gay men whose sexuality is doomed to remain a secret. A particular plot point involving one of those “Baltimore bachelors” might give some readers pause, but saying more here would give too much away.

Two men hugging in a delapitated building

Lady in the Lake conclusive opinon

Lady in the Lake, of course, may be a great novel. What else could anyone expect from Lippman, a second generation reporter whose father also worked at the Baltimore Sun in the mid-Sixties as well as her husband, David Simon, the creator of The Wire and whose colleagues she thanks in her acknowledgments.

It’s impossible not to revel in her depiction of the Star’s messy newsroom, of its ruthless office politics, and of its sometimes disillusioned veterans. Lippman writes at times with the accuracy of a reporter, though she warns that her version of the two killings at the centre of her story isn’t entirely factual. The 1966 Maryland gubernatorial race, which unfolds in the story’s background, is “represented accurately, down to the weather on the day after the primary”.

Throughout the novel, Maddie evolves from a woman whose main surviving skill is her bewildering ability to get men to like her (a woman who at one point tells herself: “My first mistake was trying to persuade a lady to help me. I perform better with men. I always perform better with men”.) to a woman who really knows that she is going to fight her battles alone.

“The men made the rules, broke the rules, and tossed the girls away,” she thinks once her investigation into Cleo’s death has reached a frustrating cul-de-sac. At the beginning of the novel, Maddie has no idea what her post-divorce life will bring. It’s mesmerizing to watch as she gets to decide what to do with it.

The story is greater than the crime, and therefore the crime is greater than its solution, making Lippman’s skill as a mystery novelist work as icing on the cake.